Monday, September 1, 2008

Key and Obama

Not surprisingly, the PM is trying to beat up the two sentences in the Financial Times where John Key "compares himself to Barak Obama" - this from the Herald:

National Party leader John Key's likening of himself to Barack Obama is "absolutely ludicrous", Prime Minister Helen Clark says.

Mr Key compared himself to the United States Democratic Party presidential contender in an interview with a British newspaper, published today.

The Financial Times described Key as "young, smart and rich", but warned that if he beat Helen Clark at the polls in the next 11 weeks, he would become the most inexperienced politician to lead New Zealand in more than 100 years.

"I'm a bit like (Barack) Obama," Mr Key, 47, told the Financial Times. "I am not institutionalised in Wellington".

"I had 18 years in the commercial world and I will be quite pragmatic," the old former Merrill Lynch investment banker said.

But then she, and her Deputy, start the beat-up, and make comparisons that Key didn't:

But Miss Clark said the comparison was "absolutely ludicrous".

"For Mr Key, a rather wooden speaker at the best of times, to compare himself to one of the most gifted orators of our time is simply preposterous."

Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen also wasted no time in attacking Mr Key.

"John Key has a very high opinion of himself, but his claim to the mantle of Barack Obama is laughable."

Mr Obama had turned down high-profile corporate jobs in order to work in his community, while Mr Key had spent decades as a currency trader, Dr Cullen said.

It all seems soooo much like something out of the Crosby/Textor playbook which Clark and Cullen hate with such a passion. And obviously the Prime Minister has forgotten the time when she proclaimed

"I sometimes wonder whether I'm a victim of my own success as a popular and competent Prime Minister"

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

But he is a gaffe meister - anyone could have predicted how Clark and Cullen would play this.

Someone still has to remind JK of the old maxim: Engage brain before opening mouth.

showmethetaxcut

jafapete said...

Hmm, showmethetaxcut beatme to it.

You don't need the Crosby/Textor playbook to find the comparison laugh-making.

Mind you, they both bget me tearful when they speak -- just for entirely different reasons.

Inventory2 said...

JP - come on, admit it - it's a beat-up. The only comparison is about experience, and that's an undeniable fact!

I'll 'fess that Key isn't the best speaker around, although from what I've seen, he is much better off-the-cuff than with notes. But at least Key doesn't have a VERY dodgy pastor in the shadows!

Anonymous said...

The comparison is crap - Key is far, far more experienced than Osama!

Anonymous said...

Helen mispoke this morning on ZB by saying Mr Peters instead of Mr Williams when asked about approaching Owen Glenn about more cash. Don't see this gaffe on the front page of the papers.

It the same old story, the left can gaffe and get away with it (Obama and 57 states!)

Others have to be perfect.

Anonymous said...

It is not the left who can gaffe and get away with it. It is the incumbent.

JK needs to remember that.

showmethetaxcut

jafapete said...

Inexperience? Palin maybe, not Obama.

Anonymous said...

Jafapete

I am disappointed that JK made this gaffe.

But let's not pretend it is anymore than what Farrar described JK meant over at Kiwiblog.

No reason for people who cruise the blogosphere to make more of it than it is. A storm in a teacup.

showmethetaxcut