Monday, July 26, 2010

She's kidding, right?

Judge Emma Smith hadn't come to our attention - until today. We've just found this story on The Press website:

A teenager has had an attempted murder charge against him dropped after a patron was shot during the armed of a robbery of a Christchurch tavern.

Ryan Randall Vlietstra, unemployed, of Beckenham, Christchurch, pleaded guilty in Christchurch District Court today to robbery while armed with a firearm, firing a sawn-off rifle so as to endanger a man, and unlawful possession of a firearm, the Christchurch Court News website reported.

Charges of attempted murder, assaulting a woman with intent to rob her, and having a firearm while he committed an assault with intent to rob were withdrawn.

Police said a man was injured when Vlietstra's gun went off as patrons wrestled with during the robbery of the Glenbyre Tavern in suburb Bromley at closing time on July 7.

He was detained until the arrival of police.

OK - so we've got an unemployed young man, who takes a loaded, sawn-off rifle with with him when he goes off to rob a tavern; pretty clearly, a pre-mediatated crime. During the course of the robbery, the gun went off, and a man was received gunshot wounds. On the facts outlined, you'd expect that Ryan Randall Vlietstra would be facing a lengthy prison term.

That's where Judge Emma Smith comes in - read this bit:

Judge Emma Smith remanded Vlietstra in custody for sentencing on October 29, and ordered a pre-sentence report and a report on his suitability for home detention.

Home detention for armed robbery? She's kidding, right? What; she's NOT kidding?

4 comments:

gravedodger said...

This incompetent sheilagh needs to go down to the "Bronx" some Saturday night and have a few beers at that Tavern. Of course she is from "Venus" and poor old R.R.V. probably had an horrendous childhood, was unable to get a decent educashun, didn't have any intention of shooting anyone and had a wailing family of various breeds supporting him in Court.
Looking at it in total he has been made a victim of rich pricks judicial system to boot. Un f@#king believable.

pdm said...

Another judge in Never Never land.

Whaleoil said...

Dean Wickliffe got life in prison for the same thing

scrubone said...

Hopefully the report comes back with only 3 words.

"Please Resign Immediately."